Wil Villaran
IT Infrastructure & Automation Expert
Table of Contents
Introduction
Migrating your business email to Microsoft 365 is one of those projects that looks simple from the outside but can go wrong in a lot of small, painful ways. If the migration is not planned correctly, you risk lost messages, extended cutovers, login issues, and frustrated users who suddenly cannot find critical emails.
Every Microsoft 365 email migration is a bit different, and the right approach depends on three core questions:
- Where is your email hosted today?
- How much data needs to be migrated?
- How many mailboxes and domains are involved?
In this guide, we will walk through four practical ways to migrate email to Microsoft 365 so you avoid data loss, reduce the risk of downtime, and give your team a predictable transition. We will cover IMAP migrations, PST imports, cutover and staged migrations, and third party tools, along with the most common issues and how to prevent them.
Whether you are an IT manager responsible for uptime or a business owner trying to move off aging email hosting, this article will help you choose the right Microsoft 365 migration method and sequence your steps in a safe order.
Many business owners and admins say things like:
- “We do not want to lose emails during the move.”
- “Our team cannot afford email downtime in the middle of the week.”
- “Which Microsoft 365 migration method should we actually use: IMAP, PST, or cutover?”
The short answer is that email migration requires planning, the correct migration method, and a clear checklist.
What is the safest way to migrate email to Microsoft 365 without downtime?
The safest approach is to run a test migration first, use a method that matches your current email platform, keep the old system active during the cutover, and only update DNS once you have confirmed that mailboxes, logins, and recent messages are all working in Microsoft 365.
Why Email Migrations Fail
Most Microsoft 365 email migrations do not fail because of the tools. They fail because of planning gaps and timing mistakes. The most common issues include:
- Wrong migration method chosen for the source system
- No pre migration testing or pilot group
- Mailboxes not prepared or cleaned up before the move
- DNS records updated too early or too late
- MFA, SSO, or password configuration conflicts
- Not planning for Microsoft 365 throttling and bandwidth limits
When these issues show up, the result is predictable:
- Lost or delayed emails during the cutover window
- Users unable to log in on day one
- Service interruptions and confusion about which inbox to use
- Support tickets piling up while IT scrambles to fix issues
A simple checklist helps avoid most of this:
- Confirm where every mailbox is hosted and who owns it
- Decide on a migration method before touching DNS
- Create a pilot group and test the end to end process
- Document how users will sign in to Microsoft 365 (password, SSO, MFA)
- Plan your cutover for a low impact time, not the middle of a busy day
Why do so many Microsoft 365 email migrations cause login issues on day one?
Most login issues come from mismatched usernames, password resets done too late, or MFA and SSO changes that are not clearly communicated. If you standardize usernames, reset passwords ahead of time, and send simple sign in instructions to users before the cutover, those day one problems drop dramatically.
Need help planning your migration?
Avoid these common pitfalls with expert guidance. Book a free strategy call to discuss your specific migration needs.
Book Free Strategy Call →The Four Ways to Migrate to Microsoft 365
There are four main ways to move email into Microsoft 365. Each one fits a different starting point.
1. IMAP Migration
- Ideal for web hosting providers like cPanel, GoDaddy, Hostinger, Bluehost, Zoho, and similar IMAP based systems.
- Moves email messages and folders from the old IMAP server to Microsoft 365 mailboxes.
- Does not migrate contacts and calendar by default. Those need to be exported from the old system and imported into Outlook or Microsoft 365 separately.
- Works well for small and medium environments where users mainly rely on email and folder structure.
2. PST Import (best for small teams)
- Great if you already have Outlook PST backups for each user or can export them manually.
- Moves email, calendar, and contacts in one file, but it is a manual process and can be time consuming if you have many users.
- Best for small teams, contractors, or environments with 10 to 20 mailboxes where a scripted or manual process is acceptable.
- You can use the Microsoft 365 Import service or copy PST files directly into new Outlook profiles.
3. Exchange Cutover or Staged Migration (best for on premises Exchange)
- Designed for organizations running on premises Exchange that want to migrate to Exchange Online.
- Cutover migration moves all mailboxes in one wave. It is easier to manage but better for smaller environments.
- Staged migration moves mailboxes in phases and is better for larger or more complex environments.
- These approaches preserve calendars, contacts, distribution groups, and many mailbox permissions.
4. Third Party Tools (best for complex migrations)
- Tools like BitTitan MigrationWiz, SkyKick, and CloudM specialize in Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace migrations.
- Best for zero downtime scenarios, tenant to tenant migrations, Google Workspace to Microsoft 365 moves, and environments with more than 100 users.
- Often include advanced features like delta sync, shared mailbox handling, coexistence, and detailed reporting.
- Helpful when you need predictable scheduling and minimal user disruption.
Which Microsoft 365 migration method is best for my business size and email platform?
If you are on basic webmail or cPanel, IMAP migration usually makes the most sense. If you have a few Outlook users with local backups, PST import is fine. If you are on Exchange Server, use cutover or staged migration. For Google Workspace, large environments, or complex setups, a third party migration tool is usually the safest option.
Choosing the Right Method
Here is a quick reference for choosing your Microsoft 365 migration method:
| Situation | Best Method |
|---|---|
| Webmail or cPanel hosting | IMAP Migration |
| Small manual move with Outlook backups | PST Import |
| Google Workspace to Microsoft 365 | MigrationWiz or SkyKick |
| On premises Exchange | Cutover or Staged Migration |
| 100 plus users or complex environment | Cutover plus Third Party Tool |
Beyond the table, think about:
- Do you need coexistence between old and new email systems for a few days
- How much time is available for testing and pilot migrations
- How critical calendars, shared mailboxes, and permissions are to daily work
A small company with 8 users on basic IMAP hosting will not need the same level of planning as a 250 user organization running Exchange and Google Workspace side by side. The method you choose should match the complexity of your environment, not just the tool you are most familiar with.
How do I decide between IMAP migration, PST import, and a cutover migration to Microsoft 365?
Start by mapping your current email system. If it only supports IMAP, use an IMAP migration. If most users already have Outlook with local PST files, PST import can work. If you are on Exchange, use cutover or staged migration. Then factor in user count and available time. Larger or mixed environments often benefit from a third party migration tool layered on top of these methods.
Still unsure which method is right for you?
Get personalized recommendations based on your current setup, team size, and timeline. We'll help you choose the best approach.
Get Free Consultation →Common Challenges And Solutions
Even with the right method, a Microsoft 365 email migration will run into a few predictable challenges. Planning for them ahead of time makes the actual cutover much calmer.
| Issue | Fix |
|---|---|
| Large mailboxes (50 GB or more) | Archive or reduce mailbox size before migrating. Ask users to clean up old folders or move low value items to an archive mailbox. |
| Throttling from Microsoft 365 | Migrate users in smaller batches, enable delta sync where available, and schedule batches during off hours. |
| MFA or SSO conflicts | Decide if users will sign in with Microsoft 365 credentials, Google, or another IdP. Use app passwords or temporarily adjust MFA during the migration. |
| Missing contacts or calendar items | Export contacts and calendars as CSV or PST from the old system, then import them into Outlook or Microsoft 365. |
| DNS issues and mail flow interruptions | Lower TTL several hours or a day before cutover, then update MX records at a planned time and verify mail flow with test accounts. |
Add these to your checklist and review them before committing to a cutover date. It is easier to fix mailbox sizes, exports, and credentials before moving than during an outage.
How can I prevent data loss when migrating large mailboxes to Microsoft 365?
The safest approach is to archive or export older messages first, reduce mailbox size, run a test migration on a pilot mailbox, and verify that item counts match before cutover. For very large mailboxes, schedule migrations in phases and use tools that support delta sync so that only recent changes are copied during the final cutover.
DNS Records Needed
Once the data migration is complete and you are ready to send all new mail to Microsoft 365, DNS becomes the critical step. These records must be configured correctly after your migration is completed:
- MX: Controls where incoming email is delivered. Point MX records to Microsoft 365 once you are ready for full cutover.
- SPF: Helps mail providers verify that Microsoft 365 is allowed to send email for your domain. This reduces the chance that your emails are flagged as spam.
- DKIM: Adds a cryptographic signature to outgoing email so recipients can confirm that messages were not altered in transit and really came from your domain.
- DMARC: Tells receiving mail servers how to handle messages that fail SPF or DKIM checks. This is important for protecting your domain from spoofing.
- Autodiscover: Helps Outlook and other clients automatically locate the correct Microsoft 365 settings for your users so they do not need to manually configure servers.
Pro Tip: Lower your DNS TTL to 300 seconds or a similar low value at least 24 hours before cutover. That way, when you change MX and related records, the internet updates more quickly and you shorten the window where email might still be hitting the old server.
Which DNS records are required for a successful Microsoft 365 email migration?
At minimum you need to update MX, SPF, and Autodiscover for basic mail flow and client setup. For better deliverability and security, you should also enable DKIM and publish a DMARC policy once you have verified SPF and DKIM are working correctly.
Final Thoughts
A well planned Microsoft 365 email migration should feel boring in the best possible way. Users come in on Monday, open Outlook or their browser, sign in, and their email is there. No drama, no missing folders, and no guessing which inbox to check.
To get there, you need three things:
- A migration method that fits your current email platform
- A test or pilot run before the real cutover
- A clear plan for DNS, user logins, and support on day one
If you take time to prepare mailboxes, confirm how users will sign in, and practice the process with a small group, the actual migration becomes a checklist instead of a fire drill.
When is the best time to migrate email to Microsoft 365?
The best time is during a low activity window, often a weekend or evening, after you have completed at least one pilot migration and confirmed that DNS changes, logins, and mail flow all work as expected in your test group.
Additional FAQs About Migrating Email To Microsoft 365
Need Help Migrating to Microsoft 365?
At LocodeSystems, we help businesses migrate email to Microsoft 365 smoothly and securely. Book a free strategy call to discuss your migration needs.